JOHN WESLEY HALLCriminal Defense · Little Rock, Arkansas

I don’t care whether you did it.

The question is whether they can prove it.


Criminal defense in state and federal courts, grounded in constitutional protections and more than fifty years of legal practice.

John Wesley Hall

Matters We Handle

State and federal courts, from investigation through appeal.


Constitutional Law & Scholarship

Search and Seizure

John has spent his career on the Fourth Amendment: what makes a search or seizure lawful, and what happens when it isn’t.

  • The treatiseSearch and Seizure, his treatise on Fourth Amendment law, first published in 1982 and now in its sixth edition (LexisNexis, 2025).
  • The recordFourthAmendment.com, where he has posted search-and-seizure decisions from courts across the country nearly every day since 2004.
  • The CourtWilson v. Arkansas (1995). He argued it before the U.S. Supreme Court, which held that whether officers knock and announce themselves bears on whether a search is reasonable.
If You Were Searched

Whether evidence can be used against you often depends on how it was found.

These are questions John has spent decades examining in court and in his writing:

  • Was there a warrant, and did officers stay within it?
  • Was the stop or detention that led to the search lawful?
  • Did you consent, and was that consent voluntary?
  • What was searched: a phone, a car, a home?

Not every Fourth Amendment violation leads to suppression of evidence. The answer depends on the facts of your case.

If this is your situation, call 501-371-9131.


Our Attorneys

John Wesley Hall arguing before the Special Court for Sierra Leone
Special Court for Sierra Leone, 2004

John Wesley Hall

Attorney

John has practiced criminal law since 1973, first as a prosecutor and, since 1979, in defense. He has tried more than 350 jury trials and handled more than 350 appeals, including two arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court, and has defended clients before an international war-crimes tribunal.

About John →
Samantha J. Carpenter

Samantha J. Carpenter

Associate Attorney

Samantha’s practice centers on appeals and post-conviction litigation in state and federal court, from direct appeals to clemency applications and removal from the sex offender registry. In Govan v. State (2025), the Arkansas Court of Appeals agreed with her that her client’s right to a speedy trial had been violated, and reversed and dismissed his convictions.

About Samantha →

Writing

Recent from FourthAmendment.com

John's daily notes on Fourth Amendment decisions from courts across the country.

    Visit FourthAmendment.com →
    Mockup notes (9)
    1. Hero: reverses the 11/11 decision. Flag it for John; don't treat it as settled. Both lines are John's own, word for word: they're the title and subhead of his current page "I Don't Care Whether You Did It."
    2. "Why John says this →" links to that essay, so the line arrives with his reasoning attached.
    3. Photos are John's and Samantha's real ones from the current site. Hero photo is a 329×201 screenshot; we need the full-resolution original before launch.
    4. Matters: these are the current site's categories, relabeled. John has to confirm the list, labels, and order.
    5. "If you were searched" is draft guidance. John reviews it before publication.
    6. Search and Seizure section: "daily since 2004" is John's own account (9/26); the feed averages ~1.5 posts a day. Treatise: 1st ed. 1982, 6th ed. 2025 (credentials file). The book list moved off the homepage to the career archive.
    7. Our Attorneys: titles as on the current site (John "Attorney", Samantha "Associate Attorney"), pending confirmation. Govan v. State, 2025 Ark. App. 143 (No. CR-24-490, Mar. 5, 2025): counsel of record "Law Offices of John Wesley Hall, by: Samantha J. Carpenter, for appellant"; disposition "reverse and dismiss" on speedy-trial grounds; eight felony convictions. Checked 11/17 against the Leagle copy of the opinion.
    8. 4A list: four real titles from the feed as of 11/16, hard-coded here. In the real build they come from our R2 mirror, never Wally's server. If the read fails, the list hides and only the link remains.
    9. Footer legal text, contact form, and Arkansas advertising review are still to come (John/TJ).